Home > Areas of Specialisation > Ethnoarchaeology

Ethnoarchaeology

By: Grahame Johnston - Updated: 29 Mar 2017 | comments*Discuss
 
Ethnoarchaeology Ethnography Analogy

The method of ethnoarchaeological interpretation was developed by archaeologists to counteract the growing abuses found in the ethnographic analogy method.

To help understand the genesis of ethnoarchaeology it requires a little understanding about ethnographic analogy. What is meant by ethnographic analogy? Firstly it is an explanation methodology concerning the archaeological evidence, based on fieldwork at an excavation location, in terms of qualitative and quantitative perceptions of human behaviour and social phenomena as recorded in the historical record.

Archaeology Pushed Aside

Ethnography was somewhat hi-jacked by anthropological researchers who approached their investigations into social structures, religious and political beliefs, and other general aspects of ancient cultural life without due emphasis on the material remains created or discarded by societies. These material remains are the foundation stone of archaeological excavation and research.

Going it Alone

This omission led archaeologists to assume the work themselves and in doing so seek to understand and answer the archaeological questions raised when interpreting the data ethnographically. Ethnoarchaeologists study and focus their attentions more on the manufacture, utilisation, and disposal of tools and other material artefacts in search of understanding the living settlements of antiquity.

Specialist archaeologists developed ethnoarchaeology to create a parallel divergence that would address pure archaeological issues. In ethnoarchaeology it is the archaeologist and not the anthropologist who is making the interpretations. Although very closely related as a science field, the archaeologist is ever mindful of the primary reason for partitioning the two disciplines.

When the Evidence is Slim

The strongest explanation for past events and practices is without question to have solid evidence in the form of artefacts recovered from excavation sites, photographs, comparison charts and every other research fact or aid available. However, when interpretive questions such as what an artefact was used for, or why is a particular building constructed with a known orientation, then the ethnoarchaeologist can possibly assist.

Ethnoarchaeology is one of many interpretive methods employed in archaeological research. It is closely linked to experimental archaeology and in some instances both fields have crossed to assist one another.

Ethnologists work with the known, tangible facts and begin to fill in the culture gaps with ideas and hypothesis. All ideas must be tested. Sometimes, especially in the case of a continuous society that has survived to modern times, observations of the modern customs and rituals may be helpful in proposing explanations that can only otherwise be guessed at.

Supported by the Archaeological Record

Great care must be taken when using this approach as, although some cultures may have endured through many centuries, their traditions or more importantly the use of tools during those traditions may have dramatically changed. All said, it is rather unimportant where the germ of the idea is from, as long as the archaeological record supports it.

Every ethnoarchaeologist knows that there are grave limitations in the preservation of artefacts in the archaeological record. Decay, destruction by fire and insect, sampling errors, geological movements, and simple human procedural errors can all affect the interpretational results of ethnography. For example, peasant tools and cooking items are found in a known rich person’s home. Explanation? They had peasant servants. Problem? Written evidence proves it to be a free society with no servants or slaves. Re-interpretation: Look for evidence of a geological slide that could have moved artefacts from the peasant section to the elite housing area.

A Legitimate Aid in Archaeological Science

As archaeologists seek to improve their interpretive skills and deliver more accurate reports they will overcome the limitations of traditional analysis interpretation by methods such as ethnography in archaeology. In doing so archaeologists show that ethnoarchaeology is a legitimate resource that equips the challenge of archaeological science.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Sallyrad
    Re: Pottery Experts
    Hi I have a very old terra cotta colored clay cooking vessel that has a sable brown glaze inside and outside. Can I send photos? Cheers Sally Owens
    9 January 2022
  • Taterpo
    Re: Stone Tool Experts
    Found a rock in central Ky would like it identify wh er re can i send pic
    9 January 2022
  • Barny
    Re: Stone Tool Experts
    Who can i send photos off a very unusual stone with markings on thanks mark
    20 October 2021
  • Heather
    Re: Conservators of Underwater Archaeology
    Good Afternoon, I have recently graduated from University with a BA in Art History, a GD in Conservation Studies, and…
    4 September 2021
  • henryW
    Re: Pottery Experts
    I found a potsherd in the sea in Greece which has a black pattern on it, looks very old. Anyone interested in trying to identify the origin and age?
    20 June 2021
  • viv
    Re: Etched Vase: How to Discover its Origins?
    found what looks like an old ink pot while digging does anyone know more about it?where can I send pictures
    8 June 2021
  • SarahMdr
    Re: Be a Volunteer Archaeologist
    Hi As odd as this sounds - we live in “Gold Country, CA (calaveras county ) and while doing yard work, have discovered over 200…
    12 May 2021
  • Jam
    Re: Pottery Experts
    Found an old statue? Under a hedge in the garden. Obviously been there many years. Can anyone tell me iwhat it symbolises. Also a few shards of…
    15 March 2021
  • Phil
    Re: Pottery Experts
    Hi, I have an extremely old looking pot of Chinese origin. Would anyone be interested in looking at photographs?
    12 March 2021
  • Jesusbaby
    Re: Types of Archaeological Data
    Examine the different types of archaeological data.
    25 February 2021